28 Comments
User's avatar
D. Malcolm Carson's avatar

It's weird, but only slightly less weird than "Black Lives Matter" yard signs in high-end suburbs and bucolic college towns across America. It's elite virtue-signaling, any relationship to real problems and solutions is purely incidental.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
D. Malcolm Carson's avatar

I agree with all of this, but as a fellow resident of the Bay Area, if San Jose, Mountain View and Palo Alto are in the Bay Area, Oakland definitely is. In fact, the SF metro Bay Area as its defined by the Census includes SF and Oakland, but not the "Santa Clara Valley", which is considered a separate metro (San Jose). But yes, in my travels around the Bay Area and elsewhere, the wealthier and whiter a neighborhood is, the higher the chance you'll see Black Lives Matter yard signs and flags in it.

Expand full comment
Manchinian Candidate's avatar

Agreed, last time I passed through Oakland it was in the Bay Area. Unless they moved it.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
D. Malcolm Carson's avatar

Yes, see my previous comment.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
D. Malcolm Carson's avatar

Oh, I think you're just getting confused between "the Bay Area" and "Silicon Valley". Oakland has traditionally not been thought to be in Silicon Valley, which started as a moniker for the Santa Clara "Valley" or Santa Clara County (Palo Alto and points south through San Jose).

The Bay Area's traditional "core" is SF-Oak-Berkeley, but most people also consider Silicon Valley to be in the (greater) Bay Area. Silicon Valley has over the last 20-30 years gradually migrated north though the Peninsula, into the City, and across to the East Bay. Pandora for example is located in Oakland. It's easy to imagine that in 2021 people think Silicon Valley and the Bay Area to be the same thing, but if so, Oakland's in it.

Expand full comment
Douglas Marolla's avatar

I remember watching some massive protest in Brussels last year after the Minneapolis cop killed a black man who had pointed a pistol at a pregnant black woman's belly. I remember wondering when the people of Brussels had become so involved and infatuated with the state of Minneapolis policing. It didn't take a genius to realize that it was the latest "event" that we were all supposed to argue and fight, destroy, and kill over.

The people at the Top of the Pyramid, the Keepers of the Narrative, read Julius Caesar's "The Gallic Wars", where JC gives you chapter and verse on how to divide and conquer. Their private boarding schools haven't removed 'dead white men' from the curriculum. But your school did it long ago. Your son's school swapped out "Tale of Two Cities" for "Tale of Two Trans Daddies".

There's a method to their madness. I'm not sure there's a method to yours.

Expand full comment
Mitigated Disaster's avatar

I get annoyed every time the US media goes through a cycle of news on the royals. I can only imagine how the English feel about importing American struggle sessions. But then again, I have never understood why there is so much international activism around US politics.

When Canada was a free country, Canadians would regularly inject their own opinions on things like American elections. When I would ask them why they care about the election cycle for another sovereign nation, they would reply by saying that American policies has an impact on their own country.

While that is true, you could say the same for every other country on the planet. If I'm being honest, I could care less about what dictator that they put into office. The same is true for the UK but Canada is much more entertaining. At least the UK has the stones to pull out of the EU.

Meanwhile, Canada is putting church pastors into jail for violating COVID restrictions while they take a knee to BLM and protest in the streets for the killing of a man in Minneapolis. Whenever I start to feel bad about the state of US politics, I just take a look at what is happening in Canada.

Expand full comment
Mitch Barrie's avatar

I'm sure they all agreed there is much work to be done.

Expand full comment
Rick Merlotti's avatar

The global chorus increasingly sings from the same songbook.

Expand full comment
Jay's avatar

That's what it's like having one state-run media outlet setting the narrative. Our little idiots (NYT, WaPo) try their damnedest to do the same thing here, but thankfully, we're built different and we have choices (for now).

Do you honestly believe that the BBC would allow dissenting voices? They actively ban them. No conservative (Katie Hopkins, for example) would ever be allowed on the air to challenge their narrative.

That's Leftism for you.

Expand full comment
TheMule's avatar

I read recently that a UK BLM leader named Sacha Johnson, who gave speeches literally saying white people should be made into slaves, was attending a party in her home neighborhood when a group of black men with rival gang affiliations to hers shot her in the head. The UK news services tried to make it sound like she was a martyr for her political activity, but, in fact, she was just a victim of a gang shooting from people just as scummy as her.

If there is anything that could honestly be called "White Privilege" it's that white people never pressure each other to make heroes out of white criminals who happen to get put down by the authorities, be it a legit killing or not. When Dylan Roof gets the needle, most white people will be like... "Great... Good riddance." No marches... No banners... No tears... As it should be when bad people die.

Expand full comment
J C's avatar

She also advocated for Black people to pay no tax so that they could accumulate more saving and buy property and business equity.

Whilst offering nothing for the white working poor.

MP Diane annot still trued to present her as activist for "racial justice"

The right still called her a "marxist" even though she's a black nationalist who loves clearly loves capitalism.

Expand full comment
CF's avatar

I noticed this via the twitter propaganda they keep recommending on the right of the site. A story keeps popping up regarding the UK and Floyd one year later... Uh... Why is anyone in the UK thinking about this at all?

Expand full comment
Smaack's avatar

"And yet rather than object to what’s really a kind of cultural imperialism being foisted upon them by foreign activists, even these Conservatives seem rather inclined to act like wet noodles."

And that's why they no longer have an Empire.

Expand full comment
DSB's avatar

Reading an essay out of the UK this morning after reading this short piece, I find the following.

"As I’ve written before, median white British household wealth stands at £314,000, compared to £66,000 for the median British-Bangladeshi family and £34,000 for the black African family. Similarly, a typical white American family owns eight times the wealth of a typical black American family and five times that of a Hispanic family."

My math based on the above quote, says median white wealth for British household is 9 times "the black African family" compared to 8 in America. Neither result is a point of pride. In looking at UK demographics in the recent path, they seem to make much of white from Wales, white from Scotland, Northern Ireland, etc. I have seen this as an attempt to deflect from a very homogenous population. 86.0% of the population of England and Wales is white, while 3.3% is black. Asian ethnic groups are the largest minority at 7.5%.

Expand full comment
dd's avatar

Can you please provide a link to the publications? I wonder how "household" is defined....is a 2-wage home and a 1-wage home, counted as "household"?

314,000BP is around $450,000....which I think is higher than US.

Expand full comment
J C's avatar

I agree wholeheartedly; I'm from the UK but have lived in many places including the US.

I find it all really odd.most people here couldn't place Mineapolis on a Map (or spell it).

Black people have been particularly keen to hold onto this issue (unlike Brazilian police brutality or the enslavement of west Africans in Libya) and bear some deep grudge against the rest of country.And a lot of white people seem very keen to be admonished for this.

What was really odd was watching football players kneel in solidarity to the US blm.when we have much more local issues relating to anti white sexual violence by Pakistanis minorities which warrant something like that.

Also the beheading of Samuel paty this year seems to of had a very small impact culturally, even though France is a lot closer.

Expand full comment
Canada Mike's avatar

I don't pay much to Euro politics in any great detail, but I thought those 'car BBQs' in the suburbs of Paris and the strength of Marine La Pen makes for a different in picture, no?

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Jeff's avatar

It's odd, isn't it? The UK, as everywhere, has it's own social problems. So why the need to import more? I'm guessing it's in line with the media's insatiable appetite for woke hand wringing.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
ih8edjfkjr's avatar

Police use of deadly force in the U.S. is vastly greater than other OECD countries for one simple reason - the prevalence of firearms. Use of deadly force by police in the U.S. against unarmed people is extremely rare. Like 40-50 or so a year, in a nation of almost 350MM. The fact that the police in the U.S. are themselves more likely to be armed in any given interaction than police in the U.K. also plays a role. Because they are armed, they cannot afford to loose a fight, lest their weapon be used against them.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
ih8edjfkjr's avatar

WaPo created a database of police shootings beginning in 2015 that pretty much everyone relies on.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
ih8edjfkjr's avatar

You are going down a rabbit hole here. Your original link is from before WaPo created the database. We have accurate data from 2015 forward. The database is accurate from 2015 forward (accurate for quantity, I should say - people do quibble on characterizations like armed versus unarmed in incidents where, for example, the deceased was trying to hit an officer with an automobile, which WaPo will describe as "unarmed"). WaPo does not assemble the database by calling the police agencies. All of these are public records and are publicly reported on by local press. All they did was the work of collecting/de-duping/verifying.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
dd's avatar

The fact that they had to learn English is a great benefit.....this coming from an immigrant who didn't establish some fluency in English until age 14.

BTW, I think Hong Kong would much rather be a British colony rather than being swallowed up by China and the totalitarianism that entails.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
dd's avatar

It may not apply to everyone, but I am fairly sure that people in Hong Kong would rather be a British colony than what they are about to endure.

Expand full comment